MGAs have boomed in recent years, but is the sector still buoyant as the market cycle shifts?
According to John Cavanagh of Octave, the sector remains ripe for opportunity, and is becoming ever more sophisticated.
He tells Behind the Headlines that the wave of entrepreneurialism that MGAs have unleashed in the insurance sector resembles the Big Bang that shook up the City of London in the eighties.
And in this episode’s news discussion, Insurance Insider’s Rebecca Perkins provides her insight from the recent Baden Baden reinsurance meeting.
This transcript was generated using AI and may contain errors. Please check against the audio before quoting.
Sam Casey (0:04): Hello and welcome to Behind the Headlines, brought to you by Insurance Insider. I'm your host, Sam Casey, and do remember to subscribe to the show on your podcast platform of choice. Today's charismatic guest spent decades operating in the upper echelons of reinsurance broking, but in recent years has thrown himself into the world of MGAs. During his long career, John Cavanagh of Octave Ventures has seen the MGA model evolve into the highly sophisticated underwriting engines we see today. The MGA sector has boomed in recent years, and he sees no let-up on this front. In fact, John told me that the growth of the MGA model is the insurance industry's version of the Big Bang that energised the financial services industry in the 80s.
John Cavanagh (0:47): I think that we in the insurance industry are going through a very similar revolution that happened in financial services more broadly 20 years ago with the advent of venture capital, private equity and hedge funds.
Sam Casey (1:05): First up, I'm joined by Insurance Insider lead reporter Rebecca Perkins, who has just returned from the reinsurance meeting in Baden-Baden. Rebecca, good to see you here.
Rebecca Perkins (1:13): Good to see you, Sam.
Sam Casey (1:14): So you were in Baden-Baden a couple of weeks ago. It's another of these big reinsurance conferences, perhaps slightly mysterious for people within the industry who don't attend. Perhaps you could just start off by giving us a bit of background about the Baden-Baden meeting, what sort of people are attending, maybe how it differs from the kind of discussions which take place in Monte Carlo and the other big events we talk about all the time.
Rebecca Perkins (1:39): Sure. So beyond the weather and the views, Baden is generally viewed as much more transactional than Monte Carlo. And that's definitely reflected in the crowd it attracts. So whereas Monte Carlo is the CEOs and your senior executives, and they're kind of setting out their broad themes and messages for the year ahead, Baden has a much heavier concentration of those directly involved in the negotiations. So you've got your treaty underwriters, your cedants, your brokers and heads of ceded reinsurance.
Sam Casey (2:10): And reading your coverage, the big takeaway seems to be that the direction of pricing in the market is no secret. What was it that really ended up consuming most of people's attention?
Rebecca Perkins (2:29): Yeah, so I'd say that most participants are now accepting that pricing is continuing on a downward trajectory. And that was kind of set in Monte Carlo. But the more contentious discussions are now around attachment points, aggregates, event definitions and hours clauses, as well as the broadening of terms and conditions more generally. So I think you could say that cedants are looking to use the increased competition and abundant capacity we've seen in the market to improve the overall value of their programmes.
Sam Casey (3:01): And there's a bit of a European skew to the conference, which is quite understandable, and I understand there's been a fair bit of loss activity in that region, which played into some of these negotiations.
Rebecca Perkins (3:12): Yes, definitely. So cedants are pushing for lower attachment points and broader protections, but these conversations are happening as the market has been hit with another active year for severe convective storms in Europe, with Kerry and Rafaela being two of the big ones. So for reinsurers, that was almost reinforcing the argument that frequency risks have not gone away. And then another hot topic in terms of timing was the French riots, which have obviously focused attention on contract wording, especially around aggregation language and hours clauses. It was quite interesting. As buyers are asking for broader coverage, reinsurers could point to this year's loss activity, as well as the ongoing loss activity from the rioting, to say exactly why these protections were tightened in the first place.
Sam Casey (4:02): A lot of these kinds of meetings are about narrative, with big reinsurers wanting to set out their overall approach and their messaging for the renewal. All of these discussions are happening against a backdrop of a big rise in third-party vehicles, things like sidecars, and there's a fair bit of controversy in the market about Aon's new reinsurance syndicate, Cortina. Amid all of this, what was the messaging from those big European reinsurers?
Rebecca Perkins (4:30): There's no doubt that Cortina has put the cat among the pigeons on this. The emergence of more third-party capital vehicles such as Cortina has sharpened the questions around what differentiates a reinsurer from a capital provider. And I suppose the larger reinsurers were effectively arguing that as capital becomes more commoditised, what sets them apart is their expertise and their long-term commitment to the sector.
Sam Casey (5:23): Super. Well, Rebecca, it's been great to hear your thoughts. Thanks for coming on the show.
Rebecca Perkins (5:26): Thanks for having me, Sam.
Sam Casey (5:29): John Cavanagh is a well-known figure in the London market, having led reinsurance brokers including Willis Re. At Octave Ventures, he is in the thick of the rapidly evolving entrepreneurial MGA sector. John is enthused about the opportunities he sees in the market, and I'm delighted to be joined by him now to discuss this further. John, thanks for coming and speaking to me today.
John Cavanagh: Pleasure.
Sam Casey: So to start off, you've had a long career in the market before coming over to Beat and Octave from the world of reinsurance broking. Can you tell us a bit about your career to date and what brought you to be where you are today?
John Cavanagh (6:02): Yes, of course. So I spent 41 years as a broker, with three companies essentially. I spent 20-odd years at RK Carvill, which was a private independent business. I started my very early career at Willis back in the 70s and ended up back there when we merged the Carvill business with Willis in 2008. And then I had the privilege of being the CEO of what was then Willis Re, now Gallagher Re, for the latter part of my tenure there. So I did that for about six and a half, seven years. And I retired in 2018 to set Beat Capital up.
Sam Casey: Rumours of your retirement were exaggerated.
John Cavanagh: Yes, they were. It was a day. It's interesting. I talk to people about gap years. I had a gap day. I literally finished on 31 December 2017 and started here on 1 January. And the Beat thing is something that I'd always wanted to do. I tried to do it in a slightly different way at Willis with a thing called Acapella. But I think what it needed was a private independent structure to make it successful. And I teamed up with my partner Tom Milligan, who shared my views about what we saw as the opportunity. So we set the business up. We actually incorporated in May 2017, but I was tied into Willis until the end of the year. So we will be 10 years old on 17 May next year.
Sam Casey (7:22): Exciting stuff. And for those listening who aren't familiar, can you just explain what the business does?
John Cavanagh: When we started it, we saw a very significant gap in the market for a platform that enabled entrepreneurs to start their own business. As you know, London in particular was always a very entrepreneurial market. That was largely because it was private capital, with lots of independent managing and members' agents that stimulated new growth, particularly within the Lloyd's market. And progressively over the last 25 years, it's been very difficult to sustain that. The influx of corporate capital, the restructuring at Lloyd's after R&R, overarching regulation within and without Lloyd's and changes in the capital model have made it very difficult for young entrepreneurs to start their own business. So we felt that we could put together a structure that was what we referred to as a full-service turnkey provider, whereby we could encourage people to come from a relatively comfortable world of working in a big company to a more risky environment of starting their own business. But we were trying to put a comfort blanket around that that says this is not as traumatic a move as you might think it is. What we provide for you is everything you need to start a business, including operations, finance, infrastructure, office space, systems and, more importantly, paper, so that you can make this transition relatively risk-free. I mean, nothing's free of risk, but we tried to make the transition as comfortable as we could. We granted equity to these individuals so that they had a share in their own business. We allowed them to be CEOs. We take the majority stake in the businesses, but our offering, equity-wise, was very generous and on the level. There were no hurdles associated with the equity that we granted. So when you look at it as a package in the round, it was a very attractive means by which entrepreneurs could start their own business in a relatively risk-free environment. And we then allow them to do what they do best, which is underwrite.
Sam Casey (9:33): Looking at the business today, it's now Octave Ventures following the acquisition of Beat in 2024 by Ambac and their subsequent rebrand. Has it unlocked things that you weren't able to do before?
John Cavanagh (9:47): That's a very interesting one. Funnily enough, we've quietly been through about five different iterations. We started off life back in 2018 with Great American and the Neon syndicate at Lloyd's, and they were a shareholder in the business. Unfortunately, within a couple of years, they decided to exit Lloyd's. So we lost our paper and our shareholders simultaneously. That led us into the world of private equity, and it was a world that we were determined to stay away from at the outset. But inevitably we needed to retool. We needed a syndicate platform, and we needed capital to support that syndicate. So in 2018, we did a deal with Elliott, which is a highly successful US-based activist hedge fund. They owned a syndicate that we acquired from them, and we did that by a share swap. Then two years down the road, we saw the opportunity in the market and needed a lot of capital to fuel the syndicate's growth. So we did a deal with Bain Capital. By about 2020 we had ended up with two private equity backers, and by its very nature, private equity comes in and needs an exit. So we tried to pre-empt that in 2024 by looking for a long-term partner that had different characteristics to private equity. That was really the reason why we did the deal with what was then Ambac. In Ambac, we saw a carrier that was in transition. They were originally a credit insurer and were transitioning out of that into a P&C business. They have a fronting carrier called Everspan. And they have a portfolio of MGAs in the USA that they've largely bought. They've done a few start-ups, but they were moving into a world where they wanted to be a pure-play, fee-based P&C business, i.e. a low-capital, high-fee-revenue business. That fits our model because we don't have any capital at risk within the Beat structure, or the old Beat structure. So we saw it as a very good marriage. They were publicly traded and in transition from a credit business to a P&C business. They were in the world of MGAs, which is our world. We were largely international and they were largely US-based. They largely bought businesses and we started them. So the symbiosis was very strong. And obviously it gives us liquidity that we didn't otherwise have, now that we're part of a public business. We've got 15 subsidiaries that at some point may or may not need liquidity. So it gives us everything we need, including a fronting carrier if we needed one. Compared to other options out there, and obviously the options were going to a carrier, a broker, another MGA aggregator or more private equity again, we felt that this was a good long-term strategic play for the firm.
Sam Casey (12:38): And you said that when you started out, you were initially sceptical and trying to avoid private equity ownership, and you ended up in that world. Was it a better experience than you expected?
John Cavanagh (12:47): Oh, yeah, I should have qualified that actually. We had a fantastic experience with the two companies that we worked with. The relationship we had with Elliott was long-standing anyway. Going back to my broking days, I was the broker for the Icat business, which is the syndicate that we bought, and obviously knew Bruce Schnitzer and the management team there very well. Great mates, really. That was a really easy switch. And they really added value on our board and brought a lot of good things to the table, as well as credibility. I mean, they're a highly credible business. Then Bain Capital came along in 2020 and it was the same experience. They were fantastic. I couldn't speak more highly of them, actually. They allowed us as a management team to get on with it. They were very supportive in terms of capital backing, enthusiasm, encouragement, their contact base and everything else. And we enjoyed a great relationship with both. In fact, Bain Capital is still part of the shareholder stack.
Sam Casey (13:47): And as you've built this business out, it's coincided with, and you've been a part of, real structural growth in the MGA market in London and its increasing sophistication too. How do you see that trajectory continuing? Is it still a good time to launch an MGA? Is it slightly less compelling at this point in the cycle? How do you think about it?
John Cavanagh (14:08): No, I don't think it's less compelling at all, actually. I think that we in the insurance industry are going through a very similar revolution that happened in financial services more broadly 20 years ago, with the advent of venture capital, private equity and hedge funds. If you look at the post-Big Bang structure of the financial institutions world, it was essentially large corporate banking institutions that bought all the private businesses, be they stockbrokers, jobbers and the like.
Sam Casey: Merchant bankers in the market.
John Cavanagh: Yeah, merchant bankers, into one big conglomerate. Big European banks, big American banks and big UK banks did that. And then there was a scenario where a lot of the talent within those businesses were saying, "Well, we're bringing so much value here and we're not getting any value out ourselves. How do we start our own business?" So the hedge fund phenomenon and private equity and venture capital were actually a response to the financial market saying there's got to be a way we can encourage entrepreneurial talent to flourish in financial services. And it's been hugely successful. Private equity has unlocked so many exciting things for our market. Drawing that parallel, I think what's happening in the MGA world is a similar response. It's responding to a few things, actually. If you look at the macroeconomics of our business in terms of where business sits, and I use America as an easy example because it's so much of what we do, we're seeing the large P&C carriers there becoming much more risk-averse. Convective storm activity, things like cyber, things like M&A insurance, the weird losses that we're seeing, floods and wildfires are really making a lot of the bigger carriers wary of taking that level of extreme risk. So there's a lot more business flowing into what we refer to as the E&S world. If you look at the last seven years, we've had 17% compound growth compared to 3% or 4% in global P&C terms. So it's been a huge phenomenon of explosive growth. And within that, what we've needed is more specialist underwriting treatment. That really is where the MGAs have come into their own. Now, if you go back through the sands of time, I used to represent a lot of MGAs in my broking days. They were originally distributors that specialised and then became underwriting vehicles. But that was really more like AIG, for example, giving somebody their manual and saying, "Look, you're really good at pest control operators. Why don't you distribute globally on our behalf? We'll give you our manual so you can price it all up." Now, that wasn't really underwriting in my view. That was taking somebody else's manual and applying it to your distribution efforts. What most MGAs have now, or at least the most sophisticated MGAs, is an underwriting engine at their very core. Both centrally at Beat Capital, or Octave Ventures as we now are, and in our individual businesses, underwriting is at the very core of everything we do. That was very uncharacteristic of older MGAs. It's now essential if you're going to sell yourself as a bona fide underwriting engine representing certain specialist classes on behalf of carriers. So I think there's been a big transition in what MGAs do. There's been a massive increase in demand because of the changing dynamics in the insurance world, particularly in America, and I think the MGA has been a phenomenal response to that. Looking at some forecasts from the likes of Conning and others, we're still looking at 7% or 8% growth in the MGA world globally, compared to 2% or 3% for global P&C. So we're still looking at double the level of income coming into that world. So I don't see this abating at all, actually. And it's very interesting. We opened up in America five years ago and we've now got proper traction there. We're going to write 250 million of premium there this year. In the old days, if you wanted to move on from working at CNA, you either went to The Hartford and moved your family or you didn't. The options were very, very narrow. Now I think what we're presenting is another option that says come and start an MGA. If you're a specialist and you've got specialist underwriting capability, we can give you another path to a career and to ownership of your own business. And that's really starting to resonate. It did in the UK immediately, because this was a market that was very familiar with the model, but it's now catching fire in America, and that's where we see our growth.
Sam Casey (18:55): There are a few other MGA incubator models, especially in the London market, aligned with this whole boom in the structure. What's your pitch when you're speaking to an entrepreneur, saying Octave is the place to do it?
John Cavanagh (19:08): Yeah, so I think that our structure is very compelling. Without giving away the secret sauce, I think our equity offering is probably as generous as anybody's going to offer. It's certainly more generous than a private equity offering. It comes with no hurdles, no bells and whistles. We are all aligned in terms of how we make our own money. We don't charge back anything other than cost for the services we provide. So we're all in this together and we have a shared view that this is an underwriting platform that makes underwriting profit. So that's one big differentiator. Another is the fact that we've got aligned capital. We have two Lloyd's syndicates that only write Octave business. So as long as our underwriting teams are happy with it, when we get talent to come over the road and join us, we can give them a 100% guarantee that it's going to get placed. We will write it. We have partners in that endeavour now, but at the very outset, we were writing 100% of every deal. We now have consortium partners that come alongside us every single time, like Munich Re, for example. Serious capacity. Again, it's all part of that comfort blanket we offer. So it's generous equity and, most importantly, a stable business. We're not fly-by-nights. We're 10 years old. We've got a big corporate structure behind us now. And I think it's a relatively safe haven to come and start a business.
Sam Casey (20:35): And where do you see the biggest pipeline of growth and start-up opportunity? You mentioned you're seeing a lot in the States right now.
John Cavanagh (20:43): We're very young in America and the growth opportunity is immense there, just because of the sheer scale of it and the fact that there is a lot of specialty business there that requires a specialist underwriting touch. I think Europe could actually be quite interesting as well. The development of MGAs there has been really pedestrian, but I think that could change. I see no reason why it won't catch fire in the same way it has in the US and the UK. So we're looking very closely at Europe at the moment. We've still got lots of scope for growth in the UK. We don't do anything in the marine area. We do nothing in aviation. We don't do PVT, M&A insurance, specie, cargo, fine art or any of that stuff. All those things are bedrock London market specialisations. And the only reason we don't do them is that we haven't found the right talent yet. For us, it's more about the talent than what they do. What we look for is a stable track record that we can see. Obviously, we don't take data from anywhere, but there are enough touch points to verify somebody's track record. We want to understand how they price and manage risk, what their cross-cycle perspective is and how they manage the ups and downs of the cycle. More importantly, culturally, will they fit in with us? We don't like rock and rollers or barflies or egomaniacs. We like nice people who can articulate how they do things well, who use models effectively and who can measure and manage their risk up, down and sideways. They're the people we're looking for. And we don't really care what they do. By definition, we're relatively low-cat and relatively short-tail, but we'll take a look at anything within that spectrum. And we've looked at 700 deals and we've done 15.
Sam Casey: So reasonably selective, then.
John Cavanagh: Well, yes. You do see a lot of dross, I have to tell you. But yes, we are very selective, and I think that's paid dividends. Our numbers are very transparent because we own syndicates, so they're all out there for the public to see, and I've been very, very pleased with our outturns in terms of our results. We're never going to be top quartile because we don't write cat and take the extreme risk that a lot of our peer group does, which is fair enough. We've chosen to be very mid-division because we want to deliver a stable result to our capital. Because we're so heavily dependent on third-party capital, we're very determined not to offer a fluctuating result, but something very middle of the road.
Sam Casey (23:14): You talk about it being so important to find the right talent.
John Cavanagh (23:17): Yeah.
Sam Casey (23:18): Having been doing this for a number of years now, what do you observe it takes to be successful running a smaller, more entrepreneurial business, compared with managing a huge portfolio within a massive global carrier?
John Cavanagh (23:31): That's a very, very interesting one. What we've tried to say to a lot of the individuals who have started with us is don't worry about running the business. We'll help you with that. So we give them a lot of spiritual guidance in becoming a CEO. What we want them to do when they first start is do what they do well, which is underwrite. It comes back to the comfort blanket. I think that's worked very well. In fact, if you look at all the individuals that we've started, and some of these businesses are seven, eight or nine years old now, they've really grown into very successful businessmen, not just underwriters. Some of them are running huge businesses now. We've got two or three with 200 million plus of income. Under any scrutiny, that's a proper business. That would probably be in the top 10% in the UK if you look at the scale of it. And they've very successfully grown into that world of not just being an underwriter or an underwriting manager, but a businessman and a proper CEO. It's been great to watch, actually.
Sam Casey: It's a slightly more exciting part of the market to be in, isn't it?
John Cavanagh: Yeah, well, being the chief executive of your own business is a very exciting thing to do. And I think we've tried to move well away from the world where you have to mortgage your house, not take a salary for five years and make all those sacrifices that used to be associated with starting a business. Now, I did that when we set Beat up. We didn't take a salary. We took a very large loan out to get it going. But that's fine. We're not asking people to do that. We're trying to say, "Look, yes, it's risky because you're starting a business, but we think we're offering you a relatively safe haven to do that in without mortgaging the family." So yes, it's a different world.
Sam Casey (25:16): It's a calculated middle ground of risk, isn't it? It's not the same as just rising up the greasy pole in the company, but it's not, as you say, throwing your whole life into disrepair.
John Cavanagh (25:25): Correct, yeah. I wouldn't say it's not risky at all, of course.
Sam Casey (25:29): And looking to the future over the next year, say, what gets you most excited about what's coming down the tracks?
John Cavanagh (25:36): I'm really excited about our American growth, actually. We've got a lot of businesses on the books at the moment that are expanding out, and that makes life a lot easier for us because if people add lines, we don't have to set companies up and build all the corporate infrastructure out. So a lot of our guys are expanding now into similar but broader, horizontal growth. Our middle market property business is getting into inland marine and so on. We're looking at portfolio solutions here and there. So they're all looking at how they can build their own businesses out without us recreating more infrastructure. So we're getting good growth from within. But from without, going from the top down, I still see the macro growth in the industry being very strong, in E&S particularly. I see the MGA world continuing to grow, with Conning forecasting it to be up 7% or 8% a year over the next five years. I think that the MGA world will gain more and more credibility as we go. And I think America, for us in particular, is wide open. I hope that Europe starts catching on as well. I gave a speech three or four weeks ago at the MGA conference in Paris, and I was very encouraged by the level of interest. Not just casual interest, but serious interest. We've had three or four follow-ups since that conference, and I feel more encouraged about that market now. Europe is a very difficult market to break into because it's such a local, parochial market, country by country, with different languages and so on. We all know the challenges, but I do think it is an area where we can see some growth in MGAs. I wouldn't say it'll be explosive, but in addition to what we're doing in our core markets, that could be quite interesting.
Sam Casey (27:26): Super. Well, John, I've really enjoyed our discussion today. Thanks very much for speaking with me.
John Cavanagh (27:30): Likewise, thank you very much.
Sam Casey (27:34): That's all for this episode of Behind the Headlines. See you again in two weeks' time.